In Boston’s Back Bay, where seafood is less a trend than a way of life, Select Oyster Bar has carved out a distinctive place for itself. Tucked inside a historic townhouse on Gloucester Street, the restaurant takes the familiar language of the New England seafood bar and gives it a more European rhythm. The result is polished without feeling formal, thoughtful without becoming precious, and centered on one thing above all else: exceptionally good seafood.
Chef Michael Serpa opened Select in 2015 after years in Boston’s seafood scene, including a long stint at Neptune Oyster. From the beginning, his approach has been refreshingly direct. The kitchen focuses on high-quality local seafood, seasonal ingredients, and preparations that allow the main ingredient to remain recognizable. The restaurant describes its cooking as Mediterranean-influenced, and that sensibility comes through in dishes such as crudo, ceviche, Spanish octopus, sautéed clams, and whole roasted fish.
The raw bar is naturally one of the restaurant’s biggest draws. Local oysters form the foundation, joined by dishes such as Maine uni crostini, blue crab salad, dressed Maine lobster, and rotating crudo preparations. There is a sense of restraint to the menu. Rather than piling on flavors for effect, Select often lets acidity, herbs, olive oil, spice, and carefully chosen accompaniments bring the seafood into focus. The menu changes with the seasons, giving the kitchen room to follow what is looking best from the water and the market.
“Here, seafood is treated with restraint, precision, and a distinctly Mediterranean spirit.”
For diners looking beyond the raw bar, the restaurant offers plenty of reasons to stay. Spanish octopus has become a longtime favorite, while the Arctic char balances crisp skin and rich fish with brighter elements. The whole roasted sea bream, one of the restaurant’s earliest signature dishes, reflects Serpa’s philosophy particularly well: a whole fish simply roasted and paired with fennel, fingerling potatoes, herbs, and salsa verde. It is the kind of preparation that doesn’t need much decoration because the quality of the fish does most of the talking.
That same philosophy extends to the drinks. Select’s wine program is built around seafood-friendly bottles, with particular attention to French wines, American selections, Riesling, Pinot Noir, and Chablis. Cocktails and craft beer round out the bar, making the restaurant work just as comfortably for a leisurely lunch as it does for dinner or an evening at the bar.
What ultimately makes Select Oyster Bar memorable is its sense of balance. It has the ingredients and technique of a destination restaurant, yet the atmosphere remains relaxed enough to feel like a neighborhood gathering place. The intimate Back Bay setting, prominent bar, seasonal seafood, and Mediterranean touches all contribute to an experience that feels distinctly Boston without being bound by tradition.
Select isn’t trying to reinvent New England seafood. Instead, it understands what already works and gives those ingredients room to shine. In a city with no shortage of places to eat seafood, that quiet confidence may be its greatest strength.
A neighborhood seafood bar in Boston’s Back Bay, known for fresh local seafood, oysters, and Mediterranean-inspired cooking in an intimate setting.
© 2026 Local Culinary Insider. All rights reserved. Sharing and linking to this article are encouraged.
LCI-created articles, editorial graphics, recognition badges, and publication materials may not be reproduced, republished, or used for commercial promotional purposes except as permitted by Local Culinary Insider or applicable law.
For reprint and usage rights, please contact Local Culinary Insider.
